DATA 05

European Imitation Timeline

From direct copying to the Great Reversal in sixty years (1690\u20131750s)

Scope

This page presents two core datasets from Dimension IV: European Imitation Evidence Chain: the ten-event chronological timeline with archival sources, and profiles of six European imitation centres.

Chronological Timeline

YearEventLocationNatureArchival / Physical Evidence
~1690Delft imitation beginsNetherlandsLow-cost substituteDe Grieksche A factory (AK mark), tin-glazed earthenware technique — not true porcelain, but visually approximating Dehua Blanc de Chine
~1693Saint-Cloud soft-paste production startsFranceEarliest European soft-pasteMusée des Arts Décoratifs holds ~410 pieces; ~20 examples of Dehua cups paired with Saint-Cloud saucers — physical evidence of Sino-European "semi-finished goods" trade
1709.11.28Augustus orders Dehua samples sent to MeissenSaxonyHard-paste imitation launched7–8 Dehua Blanc de Chine Guanyin figures (sources diverge: Met cites Fay-Hallé recording 8, SKD records 7) sent to the newly established Meissen factory as imitation models
~1710–1720Meissen Phase I: Direct copyingSaxonyPiece-by-piece mould copyingDresden PO 8638 / PE 2373 / PE 2188 three-piece set as core evidence. Copies show systematic shrinkage (formula contraction differential), stiff hand modelling, firing cracks — dual barriers of material and technique
~1720–1730Meissen Phase II: Höroldt ChinoiserieSaxonyAdaptive innovationJ. G. Höroldt joins in 1720, develops 16 enamel colours. The critical pivot from "copying China" to "imagining China"
1731+Meissen Phase III: Kändler originalsSaxonyIndependent systemJ. J. Kändler creates 1,300+ original models. The Swan Service (Schwanenservice, ~1737–1741, 2,200+ pieces) marks Meissen’s complete departure from the Chinese paradigm
~1740–1760Ormolu mount peak periodFranceIdentity transformationMarchands-merciers fitted Dehua Blanc de Chine with gilt-bronze mounts (ormolu), transforming "exotic curiosity" into "French interior element." Lazare Duvaux Livre-Journal (1748–1758) is the primary source. Madame de Pompadour was a major client
~1744–1776Bow Porcelain: "New Canton"EnglandImitation + self-branding~300 workers at peak. The Met confirms Bow products included Dehua imitation categories. The "New Canton" name directly reveals Chinese porcelain as the benchmark
1745–1749Chelsea Triangle Period prunus reliefEnglandSecond-hand imitationChelsea imitated Saint-Cloud’s imitation of Dehua — influence transmitted through two intermediaries. Chain: Dehua → Saint-Cloud → Chelsea
~1750sThe Great Reversal: China imitates MeissenChina / EuropeDirection reversalEuropean factories reach production capacity and quality maturity, displacing Chinese export porcelain market share. Import substitution completed. This window coincides with the decline of Dehua ivory-white quality (Qing-era Fe₂O₃ increase)

Six Imitation Centres

CentreCountryTechnical ApproachActive PeriodImitation MethodKey Evidence
MeissenSaxony (Germany)Hard-paste1710–1731+Three phases: direct copying → Chinoiserie → originalsPO 8638 / PE 2373 / PE 2188 (Dresden); Met 1974.356.319; V&A C.450&A-1922
Saint-CloudFranceSoft-paste~1693–1766Earliest European soft-paste; Dehua cups with Saint-Cloud saucersMusée des Arts Décoratifs ~410 pieces; ~20 mixed cup-and-saucer examples
ChelseaEnglandSoft-paste1745–1749 (Triangle)Second-hand imitation (via Saint-Cloud)Triangle Period prunus relief decoration
BowEnglandPhosphatic soft-paste~1744–1776Imitation + self-branding "New Canton"Met confirms Dehua imitation categories in Bow output
DelftNetherlandsTin-glazed earthenware~1690+Low-cost visual substituteDe Grieksche A factory AK mark; Aronson Antiquairs records
Ormolu workshopsFranceNo alteration to porcelain; gilt-bronze mounts added~1740–1760Identity transformation (exotic curiosity → French interior)Lazare Duvaux Livre-Journal (1748–1758); Sotheby’s 2022 Hôtel Lambert candelabra
Cite This Page
World Headlines. "European Imitation Timeline (Data 05)." In Blanc de Chine: A Cross-Civilizational Study of Dehua White Porcelain (WH-GR-2026-001). April 2026. https://blancdechine.org/data/european-imitation-timeline.